The Debate Continues: Boats, Or Parking Spaces?
Piermont officials and residents discussed and debated the issue at yesterday's board meeting; a decision will be reached on Sept. 21.
It's likely one of the most polarizing issue in Piermont right now: allow the Piermont Rowing Club (PRC) to remain in the North Parking Lot, or relocate it to create eight new parking spaces.
Yesterday evening, Piermont's village board delved further into the issue and discussed possible solutions with residents. No official decision was made—it will be put to a vote at the Sept. 21 board meeting.
The board elaborated on the two possible relocation plans presented at last month's meeting: moving the PRC to Parelli Park, or onto a nearby grassy field.
Village officials determined Parelli Park could house the facility if the park's fence were moved 10 feet east and a new gate installed. No trees would have to be eliminated, Christopher Sanders, Piermont's mayor, noted.
The nearby grassy field could house the facility only if it were renovated and overhauled, Sanders continued.
Mayor Sanders also noted a $4,500/year lease for a three-year period would most likely be implemented.
Though no decision was reached, relocating the PRC to the grassy field was a popular sentiment among board members. Mayor Sanders introduced the idea of moving the PRC to the field but waiving their lease; in turn, the PRC would pay the costs of renovating the area.
During the public comment portion of the night, Ellen Hart, president of the PRC, introduced a proposal on behalf of the rowing club.
"I think there is a solution that will yield eight spots while still letting us stay in the position we're in," Hart told the board.
Hart suggested rearranging the current configuration in a fashion that allows for the boat rack to stay while still creating more parking room.
"We're reluctant to take away green space in Parelli Park," Hart added. "I think this is a solution that's trying to split the baby both ways."
The board noted they will examine Hart's proposal.
Throughout the night, Piermont officials, residents and rowing club members expressed their personal opinions on the issue.
Sanders—who wants the PRC to remain where it is—explained that when the parking lot was built, the village's planning board rejected the idea of using it for 100 percent parking.
"It'd would have been like creating a mall parking lot," Sanders said. "We didn't think it was appropriate for the Village of Piermont."
Village Trustee Audie Moran disagreed.
"Eight parking spots in Piermont is a lot," she said.
Without sufficient parking, merchants cannot operate, Moran added.
Piermont resident Elyse Knight, who supports the PRC remaining where it is, noted the facility brings boaters from out of town who in turn patronize restaurants.
"Maybe we shouldn't have so many events that attract so many people," Knight added, referring to the need for parking. "After all, we [the taxpayers] are in fact subsidizing whatever happens."
Richie Stark, another Piermont resident, suggested the village take a closer look at the property deeds and legal issues.
"I like the rowing club being here, but the village should look at what the property was originally deeded for," Stark said.
--
Readers: want to weight in? Feel free to leave a comment, or submit a letter to the editor (no more than 600 words, please).
Correction: An earlier edition of this story misquoted Trustee Audie Moran. The error has been remedied.
phyllis segura
1:42 pm on Wednesday, September 8, 2010
It certainly appears that the design of the current parking lot is somewhat a fault here. By adding some sections that will apparently be landscaped in the future and shifting the direction of the cars from east/west to north/south many spaces were lost. It would have been better to have small sections for trees to be planted rather than low bushes along large sections, then some shade would be created for the parked cars and added visual interest. The rowing club initially had a corral so the boats were protected. Eight parking spaces is not going to make such a big difference. Taking space from Pirelli Park would make a huge difference to the usage of that park. After all it is really the only actual park in Piermont though there are other areas called parks they are not really parks. Now that the lot no longer floods, hopefully, why create even bigger problems. You mean it was okay to have the boat corral there while the lot flooded but not now? Petty, petty, petty. You erred in the design and should have resolved the location of the Club prior to designing the lot. You didn't. Live with it.
Erika Boras Tesi
9:48 pm on Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Leaving the boats where they currently are is my vote - it seemed to this resident that there was only one board member and two townspeople pushing to move the boats because of parking. Eight spaces is not going to change very much in Piermont, but eliminating more of our precious green space certainly will. One can always find a space to park in Piermont - even on Labor Day with the concert crowds, this resident easily found parking around 4pm at the height of the crowded day. People come to Piermont to enjoy it's charm and beautiful river - encroaching on Pirelli Park or blocking the river view by placing the boats up on the green is just wrong. We need to voraciously protect our limited public green spaces and views and be visionaries for the future of our precious town. Central Park in Manhattan hugely contributes to the quality of life of NY residents and to the beauty of the town - they certainly need more parking, but can you imagine taking even a piece of the park away to accomodate cars? I hope not. Let's give Piermont the same consideration and chance to keep it's green spaces.
phyllis segura
10:18 am on Thursday, September 9, 2010
Bob Samuels told me my comments were ill-informed but gave no specifics so I'm still in the dark. Apparently all this was figured out before the lot was completed but a new board member brought up this issue. Is this true? The lots really are there to accommodate the tourists on the weekend. At the very least racks should also be there for the cyclists who blockade the sidewalks when they make their pit stops. I hope the merchants like the weekends because people who live around the main street certainly want to leave town on those days. Funny though that the parking lot is so much bigger than the park! and one of the so-called solutions is to put the boat corral in the park. Most of the green space and other parking lots in Piermont are under private ownership which does not give anyone a voice. Row, row, row your boat.....gently....
Dennis Hardy
10:40 am on Friday, September 10, 2010
Perelli park was built by the Piermont Lions Club and is a wonderful small vest pocket park which really wasn't designed to accomodate the rowing club. That being said, the Village should work with the club to move them over to the grassy area proposed. We are a riverfront community and every effort should be made to provide the rowing club with space! I do take issue however with the proposed fee which I feel is exorbitant. While I understand the Village's desire to increase revenue, it shouldn't be on the backs of not for profit community groups who are the fabric of our Village!
Dennis W. Hardy-Former Mayor-Village of Piermont