.
Feedback

Men From New City, West Nyack Charged In Fight With Police Outside Nyack Bar

Orangetown police officer injured

Two 20-year-old men who used ID belonging to other people to get into a Nyack bar are accused of getting into a clash with police officers on Main Street that left one cop injured early Saturday morning, according to Orangetown police.

Dominic Campitiello of 3 Theresa Drive, West Nyack, and Peter A. Rutigliano of 58 New Hempstead Road, New City, were arrested after police went to investigate a disturbance at 2:40 a.m. in front of the at 102 Main St. Police said the men were arguing with staff members and that as officers tried to separate the men Campitiello became aggressive with the town officers.

Police said that as officers attempted to arrest Campitiello he pulled away and ran off along Main Street. Police chased and caught Campitiello a short distance away, but police said Campitiello then fought with the town officers.

As cops were attempting to put handcuffs on Campitiello, police said Rutigliano came from behind the officers and tried to prevent them from arresting his friend, Campitiello. This led to Retigliano’s arrest.

Police said that during the struggle with Campitiello a town officer received a cut on his left hand and sustained bruising and swelling to his right knee requiring treatment at Nyack Hospital.

As police were trying to identify the men, both were found to have driver’s licenses that belonged to other people — which police said the pair used to get into the Pour House.

Campitiello is charged with assault on a police officer, a felony, resisting arrest, a misdemeanor, disorderly conduct, a violation, and with being under 21 and using fraudulent means to purchase alcohol.

Rutigliano is charged with second-degree obstructing governmental administration, a misdemeanor, resisting arrest, disorderly conduct and with being under 21 and using fraudulent means to purchase alcohol.

Campitiello was arraigned in Nyack Village Court by Judge Robert S. Knoebel and later released when family members posted $1,000 bail. He is scheduled to appear in court on Jan. 17.

Rutigliano was released on $200 bail pending a Feb. 7 Village Court hearing.   

Bruce January 8, 2012 at 06:04 am
Why no stats on how many fights and arrest have taken place at this establishment? The Riviera was held responsible for their patrons
Scotty January 8, 2012 at 06:18 am
Let me get this straight...two 20 year olds had fake and/or someone else's ID's on them to make them older, argued with the staff from the bar they illegally entered, which ended with the police arriving and questioning them, which ended with them fighting and then running away and then fought some more and then getting arrested. You know...when I was 20 years old...I NEVER did anything like that ...ESPECIALLY when I got into bars below the age required to enter...just common sense to keep a low profile when doing something like that....boy, they get dumber as I get older.
William Demarest (Editor) January 8, 2012 at 06:26 am
This latest incident was outside the business, as was an incident New Year's Eve. Most recently, there was a fight inside another bar two blocks away on Franklin Street in which a patron was injured (broken ankle) and another patron was arrested (fled and was caught in South Nyack). Stats: Not readily available late Saturday night.
John Whitley January 8, 2012 at 08:02 am
Enough is enough. There have been several incidents involving patrons of The Pour House. This establishment needs to be held responsible. Generally, the Police need to impose a "zero tolerance" on unacceptable behavior in Nyack - public urination, intoxication, rowdiness, obscene language. A few weekends of clamping down and idiots like Rutligiano and Campitiello would realize that Nyack is NOT the place to come to in order to cause trouble.
James F. Leiner January 8, 2012 at 12:01 pm
I guess as an Historian I have to think back to when I was a kid in Nyack and wanted to join in the "fun" and have a drink. The two young men of today should be thankful for back when Nyack Police ran the town it wasn't often the cops who were sent to the hospital with injuries, it was the drinkers. I notice from the mug-shots there doesn't seem to be a bruise or contusion on either "Boy," that wasn't the case 45 years ago when I was kid. Most likely the little-boys would have "fallen downstairs" on the way to see the judge. Todayn is seems the hooligan's run our town. Hmm...let's see 2 20 year old kids...how many police cars in Orangetown need to be washed and polished?
Mary Koshak January 8, 2012 at 01:41 pm
Jim Leiner is right, this would not have been tolerated when Nyack had it's own force. Unfortunately times have changed and the punks have RIGHTS. The police officers have the injuries instead of the criminals and yes 20 year old criminals. I can hear the parents now," They just wanted to have some fun, they wouldn't cause any trouble." That's what they said about the man in Spring Valley who ended up dead. Stop babying these guys and punish them. A police officer was hurt again and I am sure somehow the family will turn it around.
Ken McQuade January 8, 2012 at 02:17 pm
This is when you use K-9's officers dont get hurt and the bad guys pee their pants !
bill Johnson January 8, 2012 at 02:50 pm
I am sick and tired of the Pour House giving Nyack a bad name! This particular establishment needs to learn how to control their premise. There are many other establishments that contol there places. Yes, I expect some problems, but this place is out of control and is known as an underage crowd.
Phil Costa January 8, 2012 at 02:57 pm
How true! I'm a retired Police Officer, and "back in the day" this fight would have been ended ASAP. An assault on Law Enforcement is an attack on all of us.The trouble is the Officers are also the ones handcuffed, and are often sued for doing their jobs. A Police Uniform has become more of a target than a symbol of law and order. There is a difference between being brutal and effective. If fools put up their hands up to a Cop, the need to know all bets are off. Assaulting a Police Officer has been made a serious felony for a reason. The low bail in this case is a JOKE. Let them sit in the jail for a few weeks. Worlds best education! I wish the officers a speedy and full recovery.
Dawn Lafasciano January 8, 2012 at 04:08 pm
@ Phil Huggy bear would be right there with you.
Phil Costa January 8, 2012 at 04:49 pm
No Doubt!!
Your Dad and I broke up many, many fights. These clowns should be thankful Pop and I weren't the arresting officers! He was a great cop and friend. He is missed.
Harvard Grad 78 January 9, 2012 at 12:26 am
This report is similar to an end result of a game called telephone. I do not understand why people waste their time, commenting on other people's troubles.. I'm sure all of you have made mistakes in your life, and that's exactly what happened with them. I'm sure there are two sides to this story but of course, nobody is going to believe two twenty year olds... If "officers" can not arrest a twenty year old than maybe they should get behind desks. I respect cops but cops do not have the right to do whatever they please.
To the reporter, I'm sure you wrote this according to what you heard and other reports, but please cut down on the dramatic comments. To others, how blunt are your lives that you have to sit behind a computer and comment/gossip on someone's mishap...
Marcos Mess January 9, 2012 at 02:31 am
Well, they know enough not to drink and fight a cop in Spring Valley obviously, that is why they went to Nyack. Maybe these cops can teach the Valley cops a thing or two?
JC Brotherhood January 9, 2012 at 02:37 am
It took a "shots fired" call to shut down Riviera. What does it take to shut this one down? Problem isn't with the Cops. Problem is with the Village that enables the bad behavior. Other towns and Villages under the New York SLA statutes pull licenses.Nyack is more concerned with providing free parking for all the drunks.
I have asked before and I'll ask again, who vetts the bouncers? I mean who uses someone else's drivers license?
BenRound January 9, 2012 at 03:14 am
You took the time to register the self serving moniker, "Harvard Grad 78. You took the time to log on and question overhead as to why people comment on other peoples troubles. You went as far as to hypothesize another "real" side to the story must exist and insinuated that the officers created their own version of reality as "nobody is going to believe two twenty year olds. You throw out the absurd notion that twenty year olds are incapable of violence and that police officers who are unable to arrest them Hollywood style are incompetent. You accuse and scold the author (this is not a pay site I might add) for writing an article using dramatic license. Finally, you slight all other posters for having the gall to sit at a computer and pass judgement on others.
I have an opinion of people like you, but I won't waste time stating it.
Phil Costa January 9, 2012 at 03:21 am
Assaulting a Police Officer is not a "Mistake", it is a FELONY.
Effecting a lawful arrest and defending your personal safety in the line of duty is not doing "what you please"; it is often a every day occurance for Police Officers. Few professions have the rules and constant oversight of Law Enforcement. Nothing in those rules require them to get hurt while doing their job. It is evident by your comments you have never arrested a person who is intoxicated and combative. Age of the person is not a factor as to the resistance displayed. It is highly likely these Officers were hurt because of restraint on their part not required by law, but expected by today's political climate. I have "been there and done that", and it is obivious that You have not. As they say-Walk a mile in their shoes!
MA January 9, 2012 at 03:37 am
@Harvard Grad 78 how was the reporter being dramatic?
As for believing two twenty year olds, it's difficult not to quesion their honesty when they've used false identification for an illegal act. No judgement, merely an observation. This board may be construed as gossiping by you (by today's standards this is "social media", isn't it?) but I don't think that you can characterize it as a "mishap" when you intentionally, consciously and willfully do something illegal.
Harvard Grad 78 January 9, 2012 at 03:49 am
BenRound, I suppose you know the "real" story, which I know you do not. Never did I once "throw out the absurd notion that twenty year olds are incapable of violence" since I do know they are capable. "Police officers who are unable to arrest them Hollywood style"... I expect trained police officers to be able to handle twenty year old kid, I do not know where you got all this Hollywood style non-sense from. Thanks for your input tho.
Lori January 9, 2012 at 01:05 pm
I would like to know if this is their first time "in trouble with the law" I think not.
Lets get tough Judge!!!!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Nyack-Piermont Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 11:09 am
Congratulations to Nyack Boat Club and member Justin Coplan! Would love to see photos of the team inRead More action!
Aerial of United Water's proposed water treatment plant location
West Nyack June 13, 2013 at 07:03 pm
This issue is not whether Rockland County will need more water in the future which it may nor is itRead More the fact that Hudson River water can be made drinkable which it can. The primary issue is the company that wants to run the project. United Water has been a lousy corporate neighbor to West Nyack allowing old homes to deteriorate then tearing them down and doing nothing to stop the flooding south of the reservoir. If we allow them to construct the Haverstraw project they will do nothing to protect the area and if anything goes wrong they will blame someone else. When United Water starts to take responsibility for its actions and manages their facilities so as to have a minimal impact on the community then maybe they should be allowed to build Haverstraw but don't count on it.
Caleb June 13, 2013 at 10:23 pm
Untrue. Perhaps if United Water wasn't sending over 2 million gallons a day from Deforest Lake toRead More they're customers in Bergen County we would not have this shortage. Hydrologists have shown that there is enough water regularly collected in Rockland's reservoirs and aquifers for our current and growing needs. Many of the "facts" that United Water is putting forward are outdated, and are based on they're own mismanagement of our water basin. Lets remember that United Water has repeatedly been removed as a water provider of major cities throughout this country (6+ last time I checked, notably even from Camden NJ) for mismanagement of water resources. I think its a prudent choice to look into a plant that we will be stuck paying for for the next 4 years from a company that has repeatedly lied and provided water with toxin levels high above legal limits to they're customers. Better safe than sorry.
John Taggart June 13, 2013 at 11:59 pm
Rockland has grown to the point that it needs more water. Terminating the flow of a river and takingRead More the water resources away from other communities (stealing what we need) isn't going to happen.
Alan June 2, 2013 at 02:31 pm
Is that what it was.....I thought it was the cicada's
Kevin Zawacki (Editor) June 3, 2013 at 10:43 am
Is it related to Tappan Zee Bridge construction?
Kathy Plachy June 4, 2013 at 01:31 pm
The cicadas were really loud today. Bugs just want to have fun!