.
Feedback

New York Leans Toward Blue in Political Stance Quiz

This online free quiz takes an in-depth look at your stance on a range of issues, then compares them to candidates' responses.

While New York may not be a swing state, and few expect Republican candidate Mitt Romney to win the state's 29 electoral votes, the upcoming election has certainly fueled a major debate among state residents about who should lead the country in the next four years, shown by the heated comment chains we've seen on Patch.

But do you really know which presidential candidate best matches your stance on the issues?

A new website launched earlier this year to help voters match up with their ideal candidate, and it's quickly gaining popularity through social media channels. In fact, according to iSideWith.com's homepage, more than a million people have taken the free quiz to determine their ideal candidate since it launched in March.

The quiz covers everything from social issues to foreign policy and answers can be fine tuned: You can choose general or more detailed responses, and a scale allows you to set the level of importance for each issue. Your responses are then analyzed to determine your ideal candidate, complete with a breakdown of your response matches.

Among the people who took the quiz in New York, their positions matched President Barack Obama's 58 percent of the time — more than any other candidate. New Yorkers' views matched Green Party candidate Jill Stein at 51 percent, followed by Libertarian candidate Gary Johnson's positions 45 percent of the time, and GOP candidate Ron Paul at 32 percent

And what about Romney? Just 29 percent of New Yorkers who took the quiz have the same views as he does on the key issues.

Seems to be a pretty handy tool, but does it work? You tell us. Take the free quiz on iSideWith.com and let us know what you think. Is the candidate it matched with you the candidate you plan to vote for?

tedc August 28, 2012 at 02:39 pm
Charmian I think air conditioning, like the eradication of hookworm in the prior century, HAS benefited southern states – so unlike those who mock you on political issues at their own peril I will not need to apologize on that point. But in my own lifetime the population of the US has grown from roughly 100 million to over 310 million. Yet our electoral votes Pat sites above (if correct) – and our continuing loss of US house seats - would seem to indicate we are not retaining anything like our share of this expanding population. In my parlance that means we’re losing ‘market share.’ In the real world that’s when someone gets “fired.”
Charmian Neary August 28, 2012 at 04:43 pm
tedc - always a businessman. True, New York has not retained it's "market share" of the expanding population. The point I made, which you wisely do not dispute, is that Florida and Arizona and, to an extent, Texas' populations have exploded since, roughly,(I am guessing here), the 1960s, when air conditioning became affordable to the masses.
"Aidan" - who gripes about almost everything from the safety of an array of secret identities - and now "Clemona" - another brave debater - purport to be laughing - although neither appears to be the type who laughs very often, unless derisively. Silly laughter aside, recent history supports my statement, but you'd have to read critically to know that. It's easier to gripe about food stamps and call people stupid. The truth is we have some of the most intelligent people on the planet living in New York State. We send more in taxes to Washington than we get back. No doubt we support those backward "red" states where the citizens are too stupid to know we're supporting them. As you see, I can be as inflammatory as Aidan and Clemona. The difference is the facts back me up. This Democrat is happy with Governor Andrew Cuomo, and would choose him again over Rick Perry, Jan Brewer and Rick Scott combined. Nothing is stopping "Aidan" and "Clemona" et al from packing up their trailer and decamping to points south if they are so unhappy with life here. Or they can stay and gripe anonymously. It's a free country.
Ryan August 28, 2012 at 05:32 pm
Apparently Francis thinks population shift is a zero sum game. Not too smart there Francis.
Checked out VA lately? How about PA, FL, NM, CO, or MO? Texas and AZ are slowly shifting blue due to demographic changes, one cause being northern migration south. Only an idiot believes that moving to a Red State makes you Red. Ask Colorado how the influx from CA has been turning out for them!
Ryan August 28, 2012 at 05:38 pm
Cost of living is the real issue Ted. As around gen X/Y/Millennials and you'll see a exodus from high cost of living Blue states, that have been doing nothing to retain smart, educated new graduates.
Student Loan debt, poor wages, and high housing costs all drive them south and out of state. It's going to be a major regional economic problem for the Northeast once the boomers start thinning out. Meanwhile, little progress is being done to keep them in state. NIMBYism and an affront to density in the name of "property values", a focus on "luxury" and "don't build, blocking my view" drive up prices, and drive them south.
John Murray August 28, 2012 at 07:49 pm
I'll leave NY when you can pry my EZPass from my cold dead hand.
Walden Macnair August 28, 2012 at 07:52 pm
You may have something there Francis - You live here, dontcha?
Walden Macnair August 28, 2012 at 07:55 pm
To paraphrase Eddie Eagan:
I'd rather be a lampost in New York than the King of Georgia
Walt August 28, 2012 at 08:38 pm
Eddie Eagan? He's been dead since 1967, times have changed.
Gargamel August 29, 2012 at 11:06 am
you are all crazy. it's all about the benjamins. money talks and people want to keep more of what they earned. you cannot do that here in NYS. why is it that the population growth states are the economic booming states? the red states will stay red states over time because it takes about 10+ years for a democrat voter to finally figure out that besides air conditioning (give me a break), nicer weather and open space, there really is something to keeping more of what you earned.
Charmian Neary August 29, 2012 at 05:18 pm
All you anonymous tough guys can scoff all you want, but if you take the time to read, instead of just responding reflexively to blog posts with intelligent come backs like "give me a break", "I need a laugh", and "Just one more bit of proof that those with brains have left the state" ( < when the genius who wrote this is still here), you'd be forced to admit that I am correct. You wouldn't want that, would you?
The population boom in the South occurred with the advent of widespread use of air conditioning. Simply put, without air conditioning there would be no Las Vegas and no Disney World. None of your "witty" comebacks can refute that fact. Sometimes answers are obvious, but perpetual complainers would rather blame someone else for their dissatisfaction with life. If you are so sure the future lies in backward southern states then why on Earth are you all here?
Francis T McVetty August 29, 2012 at 05:26 pm
Charmian Neary, Are you kidding, blaming "air conditioning"? They are moving to states that don't tax the crap out of you, that is why they are moving.
Francis T McVetty August 29, 2012 at 05:29 pm
Walden Macnair, as to your post [You may have something there Francis - You live here, dontcha? ] I live here in Yorktown because I can't AFFORD to move out right now. Something called the "bad economy" is a major factor.
Francis T McVetty August 29, 2012 at 05:31 pm
Ryan, stupid is as stupid does.
Charmian Neary August 29, 2012 at 05:37 pm
Nah, Francis, you're afraid to move because you'd soon find out you're just as miserable. People who complain all the time and blame others for their discontent tend to take that baggage with them. If you moved to Texas or Arizona you'd just complain about Mexicans. That's what people like you do.
PS I'm not "blaming" air conditioning. You need to read. It's a wonderful thing, reading.
Walden Macnair August 29, 2012 at 05:58 pm
Chairman, I do believe you're right. Studies have shown that air-conditioning was one of the key factors in the south developing an industrialized economy. Another key factor in development was the Otis Safety Elevator which made it possible to build higher than seven stories which was pretty much the maximum that people would walk up.
Since that time there have been other factors and Florida being a "right to work state" which really should read "right to abuse the workers state" made it cheaper for people to work there. Believe me, jobs that pay 100K in New York don't pay near that much in Georgia or Florida. Walt: The Eddie Eagan you refer to as dying in 1967 wasn't the Eddie Eagan I was referring to. The one I referred to died in 1995, he was the lead Detective in the French Connection Case and even though he's now gone I still believe New York City is the greatest city in the world and I stand my by previous statement.
John Murray August 29, 2012 at 06:29 pm
If what the Northeast offers you is not worth the spend then leave - I hear real estate can be had for a song in most sunbelt red states. The calculus is simple. For my money, and that's far from the only variable feeding the equation, it very much is worth staying. But hey, to each their own.
John Murray August 29, 2012 at 06:31 pm
What are you trying to say here?
Charmian Neary August 29, 2012 at 07:01 pm
That's a bumper sticker right there! My EZPass has taken me and mine to Niagara Falls, Cooperstown, Montauk, Hyde Park and everywhere in between. I love New York.
For those who don't - sell your property at a loss. You'll soon recoup your money in sunny Alabama where you can buy a home for 60K. Your property taxes will be three figures and life will be just peachy. Then you'll meet your neighbors...
Watchdog August 29, 2012 at 07:32 pm
Francis, prices are reasonable in SUN CITY HILTON HEAD, BLUFFTON SC 29909 or if you are a golfer (504 holes of golf) in THE VILLAGES, FL 32162. Both right to work states whIch keep prices and taxes low. You can get a real reasonable vacation package to try things out. Check web sites for both.
Walt August 29, 2012 at 08:16 pm
Than you meant Eddie Egan. NYC is a great place if you have the money to take advantage of everything it offers. Not a lot of us do.
SRT August 29, 2012 at 08:48 pm
Aidan, Clemona, Francis,
Facts are pesky things, as you know it is so much easier to make arguments if you don't care about them! Charmian, Thanks for the facts, I had never put the two together before. "On top of immigration from areas outside the U.S., the Sun Belt's population also grew via migration from other parts of the U.S. in the 1970s. This was due to the invention of affordable and effective air conditioning. It additionally involved the movement of retirees from northern states to the south, especially Florida and Arizona. Air conditioning played an especially significant role in the growth of many southern cities like those in Arizona where temperatures can sometimes exceed 100°F (37°C)." http://geography.about.com/od/specificplacesofinterest/a/sunbelt.htm
Aidan August 29, 2012 at 10:25 pm
CharmIan, you've made your untidy statement ... "Northern blue states are losing population to Southern red states because air conditioning has become widespread ..." a sort of a cause celebre. Let's deal with the panoramic view of population resettlement.
Technology, of course, had an impact. But infrastructure also played a key role. Airport hubs, rails and roads, water technologies (the great dams of the southwest and the vast irrigation networks), and especially the perfection of the high rise played important roles. Air conditioning was a factor, but one among many. The region has always been populated and coveted ... we went to war over these lands and saw massive migrations even before the modern technology of a/c. To offer a/c as the single greatest factor ... and no other ... is akin to explaining Columbus' success to a favorable ocean drift. Air conditioning is but a piece of the larger technological explosion.
Charmian Neary August 29, 2012 at 11:03 pm
"Aidan" - I never said there were no other factors - don't misquote me again - but without a/c as a catalyst the other factors would not come into play because places like Arizona and Southern Florida would be nearly uninhabitable. Besides the argument was made that a/c was not a factor, and I merely countered with yes, in fact, it was. I defended my statement, that's all.
I can't control for articulate people agreeing with me and expanding on what I've written. Your statements have little chance of becoming a cause celebre because no one even knows who you are, on top of the fact that all you've done up to this point is sneer and ridicule. That only attracts people like Francis and Clemona, which is to your detriment. As to history, the prior massive migrations were northern for the most part, not southern. And the western migration was toward Oregon and California, not Arizona and Nevada, prior to a/c. I'll take your conciliatory tone as an apology, as untidy as it may be. After all, what's more untidy than making bombastic statements from the safety of an alias? PS Your Columbus analogy is lame. ; )
Aidan August 29, 2012 at 11:06 pm
Now, as for the remainder of your premise that folks are ditching the north because of climate factors, well, the doesn't hold water for the present day discussion. At all.
The fastest growing states in the last few years contain but a few Sun Belt locales. In fact, the top five growth states are Texas, Utah, Alaska, Colorado and North Dakota. The next 10 states contain just two Sun Belt states (Arizona no. 7 & New Mexico no.15). And included in that bunch are states such as Wa, NC, SD, Va, Ca, SC. Georgia and FL are in this crowd ... but their population growth has been steady for decades. The next five (nos. 16 thru 20) are Idaho, Ok, Hawaii, Oregon and Delaware. The motivating factors for leaving the northeast are cost of living (including housing taxes) and employment opportunities. Many states make the list because of natural resources now being tapped ... i.e., the Dakotas, Alaska, and Texas. Odd that many of these same states have state governments that are less intrusive (and even more welcoming) of entrepreneurs and professionals. That's a more sophisticated understanding of today's population swivel. Your original premise was too simple. And your defense is likewise.
Aidan August 29, 2012 at 11:17 pm
You're air conditioning comment has always been lame. It hardly explains the development of Florida in the 20's and never extends to the land rushes of two centuries ago in the southwest. You can get snarky until you glow in the dark ... but today's population shift is based cost of living and employment. Air conditioning has been a given in this society for decades. It does NOT explain the recent migrations. NYS has a flight problem ... and folks are not packing' their bags because they can plug in a machine some place else. Their leaving because of dreadful state leadership over the decades ... led by almost exclusive liberal leadership.
Aidan August 29, 2012 at 11:23 pm
Now, to bring this little discussion into some clearer focus ... why has the state of NY lost so much in the last two "post air conditioning" decades? And be honest. And it ain't because of Carriers or Freidrichs.
SRT August 29, 2012 at 11:56 pm
Columbus was trying to get to India. What do you attribute Columbus' success to?
Francis T McVetty August 30, 2012 at 12:10 am
Charmian Neary [PS I'm not "blaming" air conditioning. You need to read. It's a wonderful thing, reading.] Obviously you didn't read my post either. I said the people are moving because of the TAXES. What don't you understand about that statement?
Another thing, it is YOUR president that does the following [People who complain all the time and blame others for their discontent tend to take that baggage with them.] Well that is true of the President, so when he leaves the white House I do hope he takes HIS baggage with him.
Aidan August 30, 2012 at 12:25 am
"Columbus was trying to get to India." Who said otherwise?
Columbus' success? What? Are you serious? Perhaps you can teach me. Have at it.
Orlando Alberto Franklin September 2, 2012 at 11:42 am
lol...i love the comments...:o)

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Nyack-Piermont Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 11:09 am
Congratulations to Nyack Boat Club and member Justin Coplan! Would love to see photos of the team inRead More action!
Aerial of United Water's proposed water treatment plant location
West Nyack June 13, 2013 at 07:03 pm
This issue is not whether Rockland County will need more water in the future which it may nor is itRead More the fact that Hudson River water can be made drinkable which it can. The primary issue is the company that wants to run the project. United Water has been a lousy corporate neighbor to West Nyack allowing old homes to deteriorate then tearing them down and doing nothing to stop the flooding south of the reservoir. If we allow them to construct the Haverstraw project they will do nothing to protect the area and if anything goes wrong they will blame someone else. When United Water starts to take responsibility for its actions and manages their facilities so as to have a minimal impact on the community then maybe they should be allowed to build Haverstraw but don't count on it.
Caleb June 13, 2013 at 10:23 pm
Untrue. Perhaps if United Water wasn't sending over 2 million gallons a day from Deforest Lake toRead More they're customers in Bergen County we would not have this shortage. Hydrologists have shown that there is enough water regularly collected in Rockland's reservoirs and aquifers for our current and growing needs. Many of the "facts" that United Water is putting forward are outdated, and are based on they're own mismanagement of our water basin. Lets remember that United Water has repeatedly been removed as a water provider of major cities throughout this country (6+ last time I checked, notably even from Camden NJ) for mismanagement of water resources. I think its a prudent choice to look into a plant that we will be stuck paying for for the next 4 years from a company that has repeatedly lied and provided water with toxin levels high above legal limits to they're customers. Better safe than sorry.
John Taggart June 13, 2013 at 11:59 pm
Rockland has grown to the point that it needs more water. Terminating the flow of a river and takingRead More the water resources away from other communities (stealing what we need) isn't going to happen.
Alan June 2, 2013 at 02:31 pm
Is that what it was.....I thought it was the cicada's
Kevin Zawacki (Editor) June 3, 2013 at 10:43 am
Is it related to Tappan Zee Bridge construction?
Kathy Plachy June 4, 2013 at 01:31 pm
The cicadas were really loud today. Bugs just want to have fun!