Letter: Locals Seek State Intervention of County

The following letter is from Jim Flynn on behalf of the Clarkstown Taxpayers organization addressed to Governor Andrew M. Cuomo and Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli


To: Governor Andrew M. Cuomo and Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli

We are writing to you to ask your help in dealing with the catastrophic fiscal problem in Rockland County. Our Elected Officials at the County level have failed us. The current County Executive and Legislative leadership have been unable/unwilling to take the actions required to put us back on sound financial footing. During 2012 the County became Insolvent. Their few attempts at dealing with the crisis have been poorly conceived and have accomplished nothing.

Since your Office performed an Audit, at the request of Legislator Ed Day in 2010 the financial situation has deteriorated drastically. For the past 3 years the budgets they developed and approved have $20 million plus deficits built into them. From the $52 million deficit identified in your report, our deficit has grown as of 12/31/12, according to the County Auditors, to $114 million and by 12/31/13 will reach $140 million. Along with this they will have run up a debt of $50 million by amortizing current pension payments into the future. Their actions and/or inaction have destroyed our credit rating.

All this has occurred while they have  doubled the property tax from $60 million in 2011 to $96 million in 2013, plus another $20 million in utility and other assorted taxes. We fear that unless your office steps in and takes oversight that they will continue their misguided efforts and put us even deeper in the fiscal hole. Due to an insane benefit program, employees are entitled to lifetime Healthcare benefits after 5 years of service, which was never funded. At this time that item alone accounts for $32 million a year or 30% of the current tax levy and is projected to exceed $50 million by 2019. When combined with the current Pension Plan contribution it practically consumes the entire tax levy.

According to some estimates the tax levy must be increased by $17.5 million for a 10 year deficit bond, $24 million to cover the existing revenue shortfall in the 2013 Budget, and $12-15 million to cover the required Pension Contributions. This $53-57 million increase does not include normal expense growth or the $4 million a year increase in Healthcare Funding that is required.  The County needs to be restructured. While some Legislators, including Ed Day, Christopher Carey and Joseph Myers, have attempted to bring some sanity to the process, we feel that the current County Executive and Legislature Leadership do not have the ability or desire to make the hard decisions required to fix the Problems.

As we feel another rating downgrade is imminent (3-6 months) time is of the essence.

Thank you for your prompt attention,

Jim Flynn 

on Behalf of The Clarkstown Taxpayers


and seriously....for those on maple ave to even consider a $4 million dollar boardwalk to nowhere...is beyond comphrehension...what revenue is it going to project??$0..and not al lthat far away is a park and rockland lake that many people walk around..with their dogs and ride bicyles..so maple ave should take their heads out of the dirt...stop reckless spending..Opps you are going to borrow the money!!forgot..
Michael N. Hull January 24, 2013 at 06:07 PM
Those of you have read this letter may also care to read the article "Nanuet's Nightmares" http://nanuet.patch.com/d/blog_posts/nanuets-nightmares which shows that budgetary concerns extend within the County to the Town of Clarkstown. In this article Mr. Flynn discussed the question: "What has happened in Nanuet that has driven school taxes up 60% in the last five years and 15.27% just this year alone? And in answer he discussed several main causes of this dramatic increase.
Mike Hirsch January 24, 2013 at 07:21 PM
Well done Jim. Thank you.
Jim Shannon January 24, 2013 at 07:21 PM
Mark my words, if all this foolishness doesn't stop ............ and be reversed for that matter.........homeowners in Rockland are going to see the real value of their properties plummet even more so. I suspect the process has already started. The fiscal situation defies reality. Shame on the leaders who have let this situation materialize. We are all going to be hurt badly because of all this irresponsible management. J. Shannon
Watchdog February 02, 2013 at 12:14 PM
We are still awaiting at least an acknowledgement from Cuomo and Di Napoli to Jim Flynn's succinct letter highlighting the impending fiscal disaster we face in Rockland. Cornell and Schoenberger, who incredibly wants to be The next County Executive, have not only restored the cuts made but want to spend MORE., even though it s clear we are BANKRUPT. The only voice in the Legislature warning of this impending disaster over the past four years has been Legislator Ed Day, who is also a candidate for CE. There as never been a clearer choice.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »