.
Feedback

Opinion: Pomona Fireworks Too Frequent, Loud

A letter to the editor on ballpark firework displays

To the editor:

Once the Fourth of July has come and gone, the fireworks are over.

Or are they?

Ever since Provident Bank Park opened for Rockland County Baseball fans, we have had fourth of July celebrations with every game. While I can understand the excitement of having this new field in the county and the ability to see the Rockland Boulders play, I am not as happy about the fireworks display that accompanies each game. Living in New City I am amazed at how clear and loud the displays are, considering they are set off in Pomona.

They are so loud that they initially prompted me to call the police as it set all the neighborhood dogs barking and I thought it was gunshots. My friends in the Pomona area have said it is even more horrendous for them. I do not understand why, surrounded by a residential community they are allowed to have these nightly "events" and they are not held for special occasions only.

They happen after 10 p.m., and besides waking some of us up and upsetting the residents who hear them too sharply, they also set off a chain reaction of barking, growling and anxiety amongst our dogs which takes quite awhile to settle down.

I am all for fun and celebrations, but this has become too frequent, too disruptive, too loud and a source of noise pollution to the rest of us. I am sure a compromise could be worked out, but as for now this is very inconsiderate of all residents within earshot of field.

-SK, New City

DF July 2, 2012 at 04:24 pm
I agree 100%.
DF, Pomona, NY
Clarkstown life July 2, 2012 at 04:26 pm
its only two nights a week
not every day or every game plan accordingly
Just Nancy July 2, 2012 at 05:15 pm
Who is paying for these fireworks?
Michael Zaretsky July 2, 2012 at 05:39 pm
Agreed! Should only be a couple of times each season! Not fare to local families and most likely a violation of local laws regarding sound
Clarkstown life July 2, 2012 at 06:00 pm
fare?
Kevin Zawacki (Editor) July 2, 2012 at 06:53 pm
Anyone else in nearby communities hear the fireworks? If so, what town/village?
KEVIN July 2, 2012 at 06:56 pm
I have to agree also. I,too live in New City, just east of town. I hear the fireworks going off, causing my dog to freak out(barking). I plan on only giving him a "doggie downer" on the 4th of July to keep him calm & cool. He has rights too! He has to be license & show proof of shots on a yearly basis.
SK, New City July 2, 2012 at 07:37 pm
EXCUSE ME? Why should we have to "plan accordingly" when there is no reason for the frequency of these fireworks, which disturbs the surrounding residents? Aren't we entitled to peace and quiet? I can "PLAN" for the fourth of July as I always do. But why must I make alternate arrangements to accommodate the ball park several times a week?? Why can't they take us into consideration?
Beytril Saila July 2, 2012 at 08:01 pm
I live in New City - by Bardonia. And YES the fireworks are too frequent and the noise drives my pets nuts. Recently there was much hoopla in the local papers about noisy neighbors - lawnmowers, blowers, etc. I would much rather have to listen to that than explosions from a ballpark miles away.
JaJa July 2, 2012 at 08:06 pm
If you can't draw fans for the baseball game itself than you have issues, Boulders. Maybe you're better off opening a fireworks facility away from peoples' homes and run that business instead.
Ryan Buncher (Editor) July 2, 2012 at 10:38 pm
To be fair, JaJa, even some major league franchises have fireworks nights. Minor league teams often rely on such promotions to draw fans. Very few do well promoting only the baseball game itself, as you suggested.
But would they do better with other forms of promotion? Is it unfair to the residents to have all that noise? I can definitely see both of those as important questions.
Donna July 2, 2012 at 11:37 pm
I live on 202 in Pomona, and I hear the fireworks all the time....definitely more than twice a week. My dogs have gotten use to it for the most part, BUT who I feel sorry for, are those poor dogs and cats, right next door in Hi-Tor. Those dogs must be so tramatized every time those fireworks go off. And its not a short show either. Cant they cut it to Friday or Saturday night? You kind of take the fun out of the thrill of the fireworks. They just seem so much nicer when you have to wait till July 4th, or New Years Eve....NOT EVERY TIME SOMEONE TURNS AROUND!!! geez, its not a treat anymore. As an adult, I can put up with the noise, sheild my dogs from it too....But PLEASE!!!!! PLEASE, keep those homeless dogs in your thoughts when you're firing them off all the time. Those dogs have terrible lives as it is, being trapped in cages all day long, with the occasional walks. The staff and volunteers are great, but those animals are still stuck there, with no where to hide when the noise starts up again, night after night. Such a shame!!
AH July 3, 2012 at 12:21 am
Vote St. Lawrence out of office and get rid of that completly useless ballpark!
SK, New City July 3, 2012 at 12:25 am
They obviously do not care....my understanding is that they were asked to stop and they won't. True or not, anyone with any brains has to realize how loud and offense this is night after night...They can use other things for promotion like baseball bat night or different give aways. Does not have to be fireworks ALL of the time!
F*** July 3, 2012 at 02:41 pm
Would the patch please start comparing actual observed attendance vs the Boulder's reported attendance?
Charlie Parker July 3, 2012 at 09:51 pm
If I lived near the ballpark, I'm sure I would be angry about the noise the fireworks make too. However, you also need to consider the amount of money that was put forward to build the park. Without fireworks that attract attendance, or even simply closing the ballpark, the tax payers will be in a financial hole that they would have to solve by paying more taxes. Unfortunately, it seems like a Catch-22 situation. Furthermore, based on what I read, a lot of nearby citizens made a big stink about the building of the park, and filed a class-action lawsuit which held up the project and increased costs. We may be dealing with an organization who knows that nearby homeowners want the park gone no matter what, and, at this point, they no longer care about what these folks think and are focusing on their bottom-line, which is increasing attendance.
Again, I would be annoyed by loud fireworks at night when they did not exist previously, and I can sympathize with that complaint. Nevertheless, the fact remains that the ballpark was built whether you wanted it or not, and things like fireworks attract attendance, which funds the Boulders, which in turn allows the organization to pay back the local government for the money that was put forward. I read that the average base income for people living in Pomona, NJ is $70,000 to $80,000 a year. Frankly, I wouldn't mind trading in my crappy $30,000 salary and apartment in Newark for a nice house in Pomona with occasional firework noise.
Clarkstown life July 3, 2012 at 10:00 pm
oh please - now that is in question?......observed attendance????? how do you get that figure???? and why is it up to patch to do it? the team states over 3000 average per game
SK, New City July 3, 2012 at 10:52 pm
Oh if it were occasional that would be ok...it is not and I am not in Pomona and the noise is so loud that it scared me the first time I heard it. Our dogs in the neighboring areas go crazy and bark non stop. There are other ways to increase attendence. In fact if the fireworks were less frequent people might like to see them! Right now they are so often, who cares?? I have no problem with the field and the Boulders...they just need to do something about the fireworls going off so s loud and so often....absence makes the heart grow fonder!
Clarkstown life July 4, 2012 at 12:47 am
Fireworks once a season.....that's the answer.....you should be a marketing manager for the boulders
Donna July 4, 2012 at 02:27 pm
I don't think ANYONE said "fireworks once a season"....where'd you come up with that???? Obviously more interested in the almighty buck and NO interest in the poor animals that cannot "plan accordingly" ...smh!
Berti July 5, 2012 at 06:46 am
Donna, I'm with you and the others who expressed concern about the dogs, but your special mention of the dogs and other animals at Hi-Tor is especially poignant. Those animals in the shelter have been abandoned, neglected, injured, beaten, or worse in some cases and now to be there at night with fireworks several nights a week is cruel punishment for these helpless souls.
I already have 2 rescue dogs; and, fortunately we live far enough away from the illegally constructed Boulders stadium. St. (HA!) Lawrence went ahead and built even after the referendum was voted down! And the cost overruns were exorbitant, and you know that we are paying for it now! Some of us won't go to the games because we are boycotting the whole existence of the stadium. It is a crying and barking shame!
Susan C Montemorano July 5, 2012 at 12:01 pm
To me it seems the fireworks are louder this year than last year. Even with the a/c on and all windows closed. I find it very annoying but what is worst is that it shows that the Boulders Management and the Town of Ramapo really does not care about it's neighbors and the tax payers who were forced to finance this 70Million project.
Just another day in crooked Ramapo politics - what's new?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Nyack-Piermont Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 11:09 am
Congratulations to Nyack Boat Club and member Justin Coplan! Would love to see photos of the team inRead More action!
Aerial of United Water's proposed water treatment plant location
Caleb June 13, 2013 at 10:23 pm
Untrue. Perhaps if United Water wasn't sending over 2 million gallons a day from Deforest Lake toRead More they're customers in Bergen County we would not have this shortage. Hydrologists have shown that there is enough water regularly collected in Rockland's reservoirs and aquifers for our current and growing needs. Many of the "facts" that United Water is putting forward are outdated, and are based on they're own mismanagement of our water basin. Lets remember that United Water has repeatedly been removed as a water provider of major cities throughout this country (6+ last time I checked, notably even from Camden NJ) for mismanagement of water resources. I think its a prudent choice to look into a plant that we will be stuck paying for for the next 4 years from a company that has repeatedly lied and provided water with toxin levels high above legal limits to they're customers. Better safe than sorry.
John Taggart June 13, 2013 at 11:59 pm
Rockland has grown to the point that it needs more water. Terminating the flow of a river and takingRead More the water resources away from other communities (stealing what we need) isn't going to happen.
drostan June 19, 2013 at 03:13 pm
A Response to the Response Mr. Michael Pointing, writing on behalf of United Water, opined in theRead More Journal News (June 7) and the Nyack Patch (June 11) that an Issues Conference on the pending desalination project is unnecessary. When it is so greatly to his personal and professional benefit to support this project, how can he expect to be taken seriously? Comments on the "desal" plant have only rarely mentioned that the radioactive tritium, which each day leaks into the Hudson from Indian Point Nuclear Power Plant - just 3 miles upstream from the plant - will end up, in diluted form, in our drinking water. Problem is, although highly diluted, there's no way to filter out tritium since it is chemically identical to water. Worse, there's no known safe exposure level. Like "normal" water, tritium goes into your body as fast as you drink it. Good news: about half of the tritium you do drink is filtered out by the kidneys within about ten days. Bad news: When your kitchen faucet keeps providing you with small amounts of tritium day after day, it tends to keep whatever levels you have in your body elevated. Welcome to your future, Rockland. Say, how about cracking open a nice plastic bottle of Deer Park for mixing up that baby formula? Why does United Water want this project to go forward so quickly as to necessarily preclude a thorough public education process in which all the variables and all the options can be openly discussed? What if one day you decided you don't like UW anymore and you wished the water utility was still owned by the government and not the private sector, because at least that way through your vote, you could democratically elect new people who would shut the plant down (whereas you can never "vote out" a private corporation from owning the pipes that carry your drinking water)? Let's just say arbitrarily that for the first ten years following completion of this more or less irreversible project there was an average of 500 additional picocuries of tritium per liter showing up in drinking water in Rockland County that was not there before. Even the NRC says Indian Point emits tritium into the ground water and presumably into the Hudson as well, since Hudson water is what flows - 24 hours a day - into and out of the power plant, cooling the atomic reaction that creates electrical power). In 1976 the EPA decided (more or less arbitrarily) that 20,000 picocuries of radioactivity would be roughly the "safe" upper limit for human consumption (due to drinking tritium or any other radionuclide). I say "arbitrarily" because I am aware of no one who has actually tried this since then, to see if it really turned out to be safe. Whose insurance policy would make Rockland homeowners whole again if at some future point tritium (or other radionuclide) levels skyrocketed while property values plummeted? Maybe something so terrible could never, ever happen. I certainly hope it couldn't. But why are we residents the guinea pigs, and how come we pay more - not less - for our water just so UW can do more business and, of course, collect more in utility bills? By the way, Fukushima was also never ever supposed to happen. Human health is not something you go back and study all over again once you realize you've lost it. Doesn't Rockland County have enough cancer already? Dan Rostan Nyack